Talk:Major roguelikes

From RogueBasin
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Reverted spam (back to last reversion if applicable))
Line 1: Line 1:
[ paxil online] [ didrex online] [,51 ultracet online] [,47 sonyericsson ringtones] [ mono ringtones] [ valium online] [ diazepam] [ cheap clomid] [ cheap fioricet] [,37 cheap paxil] [ kyocera ringtones] [ free mp3 ringtones] [,31 free mp3 ringtones] [ alprazolam online] [ free alltel ringtones] [ alprazolam online] [ lipitor online] [ hydrocodone online] [,54 verizon ringtones] [ cheap levitra] [ tramadol online] [ hydrocodone online] [ sprint ringtones] [ cheap xanax] [,43 free real ringtones] [ free tracfone ringtones] [,40 buy propecia] [ order ativan] [ free samsung ringtones] [,50 cheap tramadol] [ buy didrex] [ clomid] [ order lorazepam] [,42 samsung ringtones] [ albuterol online] [ zyban online] [ cheap soma] [ clonazepam] [ paxil online] [ free real ringtones] [ sildenafil online] [,45 cheap soma] [ ambien online] [ cheap wellbutrin] [ adipex online] [ propecia online] [ free real ringtones] [ diethylpropion online] [ polyphonic ringtones] [ cheap rivotril] [ jazz ringtones] [ cheap lipitor] [ cheap lorazepam] [ cheap prozac] [ carisoprodol online] [ free polyphonic ringtones] [ tenuate online] [ valium online] [ polyphonic ringtones] [ lipitor online] [ free ringtones] [ cheap phentermine] [ sagem ringtones] [ free free ringtones] [ buy ultracet] [ ortho online] [ buy vigrx] [,33 online nexium] [,28 buy meridia] [ free sharp ringtones] [ music ringtones] [,20 diazepam online] [ cheap carisoprodol] [ but wellbutrin] [ meridia online] [,23 free ringtones] [,57 xanax online] [ mtv ringtones] [ fioricet online] [ free mp3 ringtones] [ free nextel ringtones] [ cheap adipex] [ cheap xanax] [,41 sagem ringtones] [ cheap diazepam] [ cheap clonazepam] [,39 free polyphonic ringtones] [ carisoprodol online] [ wellbutrin online] [ kyocera ringtones] [ cheap ativan] [ order viagra] [,27 buy lorazepam] [ cheap ultram] [ free kyocera ringtones] [,10 alprazolam online] [ alltel ringtones] [ cheap ambien] [ cheap vicodin] [,30 free motorola ringtones] [ free sony ericsson ringtones] [ free punk ringtones] [ viagra online] [ phentermine] [ xanax online] [ buy ultram] [ valium online] [,17 cingular ringtones] [,8 adipex online] [ order cyclobenzaprine] [ propecia online] [ cheap tenuate] [ cheap carisoprodol] [ cheap ultracet] [ cheap pharmacy online] [ wwe ringtones] [ cheap diazepam] [ xenical online] [ free nokia ringtones] [ free qwest ringtones] [ cheap zanaflex] [ diazepam online] [ free verizon ringtones] [ motorola ringtones] [ order lortab] [ prozac online] [ free ericsson ringtones] [ cheap ortho] [,19 cheap cyclobenzaprine] [ celexa online] [ free free ringtones] [ phentermine online] [ free cool ringtones] [ cheap prozac] [,44 qwest ringtones] [ order cialis] [ sprint ringtones] [ nexium online] [ real ringtones] [ free sagem ringtones] [ free tracfone ringtones] [ nokia ringtones] [ free punk ringtones] [ free mp3 ringtones] [ free sony ringtones] [,12 buy ativan] [ hgh] [ free midi ringtones] [ free alltel ringtones] [ cheap flexeril] [ free sony ericsson ringtones] [ motorola ringtones] [ cheap vicodin] [ tracfone ringtones] [ soma online] [ order levitra] [ motorola ringtones] [ didrex online] [ cheap sildenafil] [ pharmacy online online] [ zoloft online] [ order hydrocodone] [ sony ringtones] [ cingular ringtones] [ online viagra] [ buy paxil] [ buy ambien] [ lortab online] [ hydrocodone online] [ vigrx online] [ cheap ativan] [ buy hgh] [ cheap sildenafil] [ buy viagra] [ ortho online] [ nextel ringtones] [ lisinopril online] [,24 free funny ringtones] [,46 sony ericsson ringtones] [ vicodin online] [,25 hydrocodone] [ ativan online] [ mono ringtones] [,18 clonazepam] [ levitra] [ sprint ringtones] [ cheap cialis] [ free sony ringtones] [,26 order levitra] [ cheap zanaflex] [ but phentermine] [ celexa online] [ ultracet online] [ wwe ringtones] [ sharp ringtones] [,36 buy norco] [ soma] [ ultracet online] [ cingular ringtones] [ cheap adipex] IMBO [[ToME]] as more than enough players to not fall in the [[Stable_games|"stable but not much played"]] category.
IMBO [[ToME]] as more than enough players to not fall in the [[Stable_games|"stable but not much played"]] category.

Revision as of 13:06, 12 June 2007

IMBO ToME as more than enough players to not fall in the "stable but not much played" category.

There has been some miscommunication if it is believed that the Stable_games category means that the games are not much played! I have been opposed to this hierarchy from the beginning due to just this sort of problems.

I think this category should be reserved for genre defining roguelikes. I do not have any clear criterion for determining this (which is why I think trying to categorize this way is foolish and likely to just lead to bad feelings), but I do not believe ToME is there.

One approach to make this more systematic would be just to limit Major Roguelikes to those with USENET groups. This would remove Crawl, but if it allows us to move forward without needless infighting, I'm all for it.

Perhaps the category should be renamed to Influential Roguelikes, where the game's influence is defined by how much the game is being copied by other popular games and having other popular games derived from the game.

This would have a bias toward games with sources available and licensed to allow derived works, but that seems reasonable to me. The more open a game is, the more it CAN influence other game developers.

So, if we look at the tree that was just put on the Major Roguelikes page, everything with a child node influenced its children, and should count as an Influential Roguelikes. List the leaf nodes in the Stable section, including Adom, Crawl, SLASH'EM. ZAngband seems on the border to me, since it seems to have spawned as many variants as Angband has.

  1. Influential isn't driven by open source. One hardly needs the source code to be influenced by another game!
  2. I like the idea of branching based on evolution/game type. I'm most interested in branching based on game type. This is the reason for the HackLike vs Band distinction.
  3. I'm curious as to why you include Nethack on the list but exclude Adom. If you count variants based purely on code, both are equally sparse and should be crowded out by ZAngband and other Angband Variants. If you count variants based on style, however, I would contend that there is no shortage of Adom deriviatives. Avanor, for example, clearly lists itself as Adom inspired.
  4. I think any organizatin of Major Roguelikes should at a minimum include the* "approved" roguelikes.

If you can find popular games that copy Adom, then by all means put it in! My explanation in that last paragraph was working from the tree diagram, which focuses more on what I called the 'derivation' aspect of Influence, as opposed to the 'copying' aspect.

I think Usenet should be ignored, because the games listed and omitted there are chosen more by accident of history and bureaucracy than they are by merit. The hierarchy is a historial artifact, but this page is attempting to describe the way things are now.

Okay, I have moved the Usenet listing to the end, and having the free-for-all listing as the first. With luck, the number of roguelikes added to the canon this way will be small enough that we don't need to get sucked into arguing what constitutes "popular" or "influential".

Personal tools